APi_ZZ - Scaffold
I like percussive, rhythmic elements.
In the beginning the bass is very dominant for me.
Nice change at 0:50, after 0:50 I like the entrance of the choir, but it seems a bit static. Dynamically it could be more exciting.
On the whole I like it, because it is a pleasant composition, with a calm sound, but with the rhythm there is still a good excitement and movement.
bpackard - Framework
Nice trailerish track. I especially like the climax part. The structure of the song is classic, it seems a tiny bit long (esp. the intro and ActI together), but that could be my taste.
Good instrumentals, classic choices, one or two of the tools are my favorites too.
Small critique I would do differently: you wrote that you particularly like the brass in it. Too bad they would almost cease to exist in mono. The correlation in the middle is not very good. I would improve that a bit.
Arelem - Torn Down
Nice lo-fi start and nice buildup.
As I listened to each song in turn, I had to turn it down because it was extremely loud
![Smile :)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
I like the structure and the clarity of the mix.
and finally... the song fits the theme very well.
Crosshatched - Frame for Nothing
What an emotional song.
1:12- nice composition, great harmony
Mix: especially at the beginning, I'm not really happy with the phazing issues.
It's mostly the emotional content and surges that got me about the song. I like it.
Rafitown - Scaffold Theme
I like the composition, it has good ideas.
The good ideas don't quite add up to a whole song for me, but all of them are good and sound good.
Good piano playing. The piece testifies to a very good musical education and experience, it was a pleasure to listen to.
KukoBass - Scaffold Ska
Oh, I remember a ska competition here from year(s) ago. it brings back those memories. Love the style, would be nice to have a similar competition again.
I like the rhythm, the choice of instruments wouldn't be bad either, very good walking bass line, but I don't like the mix very much unfortunately. Despite the Mix Monolyth I have issues with the balance. The brass part (esp. trombone is too loud for me) the rocksichord is thin in itself (in the latter case, the sound of the instrument may not be the best choice).
EsteveCorbera - La Bombeta Al Sostre Del Garatge
Very good start, perfect start. Until 0:49 it's absolutely fine.
Unfortunately after that the instruments start to work in a completely different space, rhythm and scale.
Even if there were a chaos theory behind it, 1-2 out of the three should be common.
After 1:42 comes another theme, much, much better.
It's a shame about the interjected part of the song, because overall it captured the theme well, although your work in recent months has been a bit better.
DocJon - Crane Town Man
When I first started listening to the song, I wondered how the theme of the month would relate to it, but it couldn't have been better...
I really like the instrumentation, the mix, the chorus is pleasantly catchy.
The text is also very apt and good.
Cdbaksu - Molly
Great composition, nice, good to listen.
Especially after 2:40 at some parts I would apply e.g. a dynEQ, because the main instrument is too loud and sometimes resonant for me.
The outro at the end is a bit unexpected, especially considering that the song practically starts "in medias res".
Overall an impressive piece of music, demonstrating excellent musicality.